Sauces & Spreads

A fresh take on a favorite summer cocktail! Our Margarita Mix is full of flavor, and the combination of lime, lemon, and grapefruit juices give it a nuanced complexity that's bolstered by orange oil and a touch of agave. Just add one part tequila to two parts mix for the perfect margarita!

This best-selling mix is a Midwestern twist on a classic! It's filled with hand-grated Michigan-grown horseradish and aromatic dill, and it makes a perfect addition to brunch.

Details: 25.5 oz. Unopened: 18 months. Opened and refrigerated: 4 months.
Ingredients: Tomato juice (tomatoes, citric acid), tomatoes (tomatoes, tomato juice, salt, citric acid), white wine vinegar (contains sulfites), sugar, Worcestershire Sauce (distilled white vinegar, molasses, sugar, water, salt, onions, anchovies, garlic, cloves, tamarind extract, natural flavorings, chili pepper extract), garlic, salt, horseradish, dill, spices, distilled white vinegar. Contains fish (anchovies).

Full of tartness from Michigan-grown cherries, Petoskey, Michigan's, American Spoon Cherry BBQ Grilling Sauce has fresh orange zest and a touch of cumin. Brush dazzlingly sophisticated cherry flavor over pork tenderloin, grilled duck or chicken breast, roasted leg of lamb, or even grilled brats.

The seductive sweetness distilled from Michigan Sugar Maples commingled with zesty tomatoes, spices and seasonings is fabulous on beef, pork, poultry and baked beans. The balanced flavor of this maple bbq sauce has almost universal appeal!

This sophisticated mustard features whole yellow and black mustard seeds soaked in vinegar and Michigan sparkling wine. The seeds become plump, tender and toothsome as they’re infused with the wine’s complexity and then burst with every taste, releasing their flavor in a perfect balance of sweet and heat. This delicious elemental specialty pairs beautifully with a range of foods, especially robust fare like burgers, steak and cured meats.

A mildly hot and sweet, translucent orange jelly flecked with colorful bits of peppers. Spoon a jar over baked brie as it comes from the oven for something beautiful and heavenly. Also truly delicious on gorgonzola or almost any soft cheese.

Hints of fresh ginger give juicy Bartlett Pears from Gary Frederickson's Northport, Michigan orchard a soft, subtle kick and lovely warm sweetness. This lively butter is delicious paired with soft cheeses, spread over thick slices of rustic bread, or served with pork.

American Spoon's Apricot Jam is bright and lush, with a familiar flavor that's like biting into a fresh apricot. Made from crushed apricots grown for us by Marty Jelinek out on Michigan's Leelanau Peninsula, with a splash of orange juice, honey, and orange blossom water. This vibrant jam is perfect on thick buttered toast or for simple baking.

Details: 9.5 oz. Unopened - 24 months.  Opened & refrigerated - 2 months.
Ingredients: Apricots, sugar, orange juice, honey, lemon juice, pectin, orange blossom water (bitter orange blossoms, water).

Tart Michigan Montmorencies are most commonly baked into pie, but true devotees—enamored of their pleasing pucker—eat them out-of-hand at market stands throughout Northern Michigan. American Spoon's Sour Cherry Spoon Fruit celebrates the vibrant tartness of Michigan's most famous fruit in this thick jam sweetened with concentrated fruit juice and filled with whole bright-red cherries. Spread it over toast or swirl it into yogurt for a simple, satisfying morning meal.

Loaded with Montmorency Cherries, Michigan's most famous fruit. With its deep red color and brightly tart flavor, this perennial Fruitlands favorite has distinguished itself as the finest example of Michigan's most beloved preserve.

An instant favorite. The simple maple-y sweetness of this buttery caramel sauce is the perfect partner for creamy vanilla ice cream, or spooned over a warm waffle with a cup of coffee for the best breakfast.

A classic Chocolate Fudge Sauce for classic sundaes. American Spoon features deeply delicious craft chocolate from Askinosie Chocolate in Missouri, with rich Midwestern cream and a hint of vanilla. Almost everyone at American Spoon has admitted to standing in front of the fridge and eating this straight out of the jar. We just can't resist its full chocolaty flavor and thick, silky texture. Spoon it over ice cream, smooth it over cakes, or dip fresh berries in it. Or, like us, just grab a spoon. A 2016 Good Food Awards Winner.

The truest taste and texture of tart cherries ever captured in a jar. Whole pitted Montmorency cherries are suspended in a rich ruby-red cherry syrup.

The perfect gift for your sweetie! Enjoy Finding Home's certified organic maple syrup packaged in a beautiful bottle with a metal collar. This 8 oz, half pint bottle is 100% hand crafted happiness!

The perfect gift for your sweetie! This bottle of maple syrup is representative of the perfect relationship. Finding Home uses Orange County Distillery rye barrels to age their syrup, creating the most perfect flavor addition. Doesn’t get much better than that! 

• 2020 Product of the Year, Specialty Food Association
• 2020 Gold Sofi Winner, Specialty Food Association
• Good Food Awards Winner 2020 in the Pantry Category

The perfect gift for your sweetie! Finding Home Farms Sweet Maple Mustard is sweet and delicious. Excellent to add to your recipes or use on their own. 7oz jar.

The perfect gift for your sweetie! Finding Home Farms Maple Horseradish Mustard is sweet and savory. Excellent to add to your recipes or use on their own. 7oz jar.

Introducing TRUFF’s special White Truffle edition. The White Truffle hot sauce is a curated blend of ripe chili peppers, organic agave nectar, white truffle, and a hint of organic coriander. Landing on a brighter sensation, White Truff includes a special edition VIP box, fully designed to embody the essence of the holidays.

The Triple Berry Conserve captures the aromatic succulence of Early Glow Strawberries, the dark complexity of black raspberries, and the deep, jammy sweetness of Rubel Blueberries. The flavors meld together in their copper kettles, creating an intensely summery conserve that everyone at American Spoon adores.

A classic Midwestern condiment made with Northern Michigan honey. Thick, creamy, and rich with butter, this mustard is hot and sweet and perfect for almost any sandwich.